PICTURE BOOK BUZZ
  • Home
  • About
  • Books
  • Book Trailers
  • Blog

​NINE RHYME CRIMES TO AVOID WHEN WRITING A RHYMING PICTURE BOOK  by Vivian Kirkfield

1/28/2019

30 Comments

 
Picture
Most of us grew up listening to Mother Goose rhymes like Jack and Jill:
Jack and Jill went up the hill
To fetch a pail of water
Jack fell down and broke his crown
And Jill came tumbling after.

We also loved hearing stories like Goodnight Moon:
In the great green room there was a telephone and a red balloon
 and a picture of the cow jumping over the moon.

And those of you who work with kids know that young children LOVE rhyming books.

So, why do agents and editors caution authors NOT to write in rhyme? The last time I looked, there were LOTS of new rhyming stories on bookstore and library shelves. Obviously, publishers are buying them.

There are TWO main reasons why editors discourage writers from writing in rhyme.

The first is that it is difficult to translate rhyme into other languages and if an editor is looking to acquire world rights and publish a book in other languages for other countries, prose is much easier.

The second, more important reason, is that there is a lot of BAD rhyme going around. Writing a picture book in rhyme is more than just making sure the last word in each line rhymes. Here’s a list of nine rhyme crime examples:

1.  Too simple or cliché.
     The mouse is small.
     The man is tall.
     He throws a ball.
     And that is all.

2.  Frivolous or forced, which means if you didn’t need that particular word to make the rhyme, you       wouldn’t have used it.
      I went to visit Henny Penny
     She is my friend, just like Jack Benny. (doesn’t make sense unless your story is about Jack Benny)

3. Inverted speech:
     I hop around on my left foot.
     And on my head my hat I put.

4. Seussian rhymes…which isn’t to say you can’t make up words, but they’d better be part of an amazing story because your manuscript will be compared to the master of invented words, Dr. Seuss.
     The tiger is loose
     He rides a caboose
     And shares a cage with a young falla-noose.

5. Near-rhymes. You might be able to get away with one if the rest of the manuscript is perfect in every other way. And yes, I know there are published books out there with lots of near rhymes.
     Down the road we both did amble
     In my hand I held a candle.

6. Regional rhymes. This is a big problem because depending on where you live (in the U.S. for instance), people pronounce words differently. For example, in Boston ‘park’ is pronounced ‘pack’.
     I put the car into park
     And picked up my sack.
So, someone in Boston will read that as a rhyme, but in Florida, maybe not so much.

7. Poor rhythm. Rhythm is an important element in anything that needs to be read aloud, even a political speech. Picture books, especially, need to have pleasing rhythm, whether they are prose or poetry.
     Rain, rain, go away
     Come again some other day.
That sounds fine, right? But how about:
     Rain, rain, go away
     Don’t come on February 11th which is my birthday.
There are way too many beats in the second line…if they are couplets, each line has to mirror the matching line in stressed beats. What are couplets and stressed beats, you ask? Well, that’s a whole other blog post. 😊

8. Unnatural stress. When we speak or read aloud, each word in the sentence is stressed or not. When we want things to rhyme, sometimes we purposely read in a way that isn’t natural. But our readers won’t know what we had in mind. I’ve put in bold the syllables that should be stressed. Even though ‘slide’ and ‘side’ rhyme, the stress for those words is on the first syllable and ‘land’ and ‘lake’ don’t rhyme.
     There's a landslide
     By the lakeside

9. Using the same word.
     I saw the ship had run aground
     While masts and sail lay on the ground.
 
 
What should you do if you love to write in rhyme?
  • Keep writing!
  • Read lots of rhyming books that have been published recently. Use them as mentor texts to help you craft your own story.
  • Check out online poetry classes like Renee LaTulippe’s Lyrical Language Lab (free mini-lessons available on her website) and places like Rhymezone.com and Thesaurus.com that will help you find the words you need.
  • Most importantly, make sure your STORY is there. Because the story is what it’s all about.
  • Some experts advise that you write your rhyming story in prose first. Then, when you have a fabulous story, see if it is even better in rhyme. Or, if you get stuck when you are writing in rhyme, try writing that one line or verse in prose. How would you say it? How could you change it up, while still staying true to the story line?
    ​
The good news is that publishers ARE buying rhyming stories. I wrote a rhyming manuscript back in 2013. I revised it. I shared it with critique buddies. And revised some more. When I thought I had polished it sufficiently, I sent it to a publisher…who passed on it. I put the story away and took it out again last year and showed it to another critique buddy who fell in love with it and brought it to her long-time editor who fell in love with it. I’m thrilled to say that Pippa’s Passover Plate will be published by Holiday House on February 5, 2019.

Picture
Here’s an excerpt from the refrain:
Quiver, quaver, shiver, shake.
Cats make Pippa cringe and quake.
​

Take heart…rhyming picture books are getting out into the world. Just make sure you write a great story that has an opening that hooks the reader, a plot that is well-paced, characters the reader can connect to, a satisfying ending…and, oh yes, please avoid the nine rhyme crimes.
 
Vivian’s bio
Vivian Kirkfield has paved her career path with picture books. From shelving them when she worked at a children’s library during her college years, to reading them with her students when she taught kindergarten, her goal has always been to help kids become lovers of books and reading. She is the author of Pippa’s Passover Plate (Holiday House, Feb 2019)); Four Otters Toboggan: An Animal Counting Book (Pomegranate Press, March 2019); Sweet Dreams, Sarah (Creston Books, May, 2019); Making Their Voices Heard: The Inspiring Friendship of Ella Fitzgerald and Marilyn Monroe (Spring 2020); and From Here to There: Inventions That Changed the Way the World Moves (Fall 2020). Vivian lives in the quaint New England village of Amherst, New Hampshire where the old stone library is her favorite hangout and her young grandson is her favorite board game partner. You can visit her website at Picture Books Help Kids Soar where she reviews picture books, interviews authors, and hosts the #50PreciousWords Challenge for writers.

​You can connect with her on 
Facebook, Twitter, Linkedin, and Pinterest
30 Comments
Tina Cho link
2/3/2019 10:43:55 pm

Wonderful explanations and examples of rhyme crimes, Vivian! I'm certainly guilty!

Reply
Vivian Kirkfield link
2/3/2019 10:57:38 pm

Oh my gosh...your writing is so lyrical and beautiful, Tina!

Reply
Laurie Smollett Kutscera link
2/4/2019 06:30:15 pm

Bless you Vivian!!! These are excellent examples. I’ve hesitated to share my work in rhyme but I think I may pull one of my favorites out and try to polish it. Great post!

Reply
Pam Jones Nill
2/4/2019 09:39:35 am

Great tips Vivian, Thanks.

Reply
Stuart Kirkfield link
2/4/2019 02:36:10 pm

Hope they will be helpful, Pam! When I look at the first stories I wrote in rhyme, I can fine every single one of those rhyme crimes!!!

Reply
Lisa Amstutz link
2/4/2019 10:28:21 am

This is spot on - great post!

Reply
Vivian Kirkfield link
2/4/2019 06:59:30 pm

Hi Lisa...thank you so much...glad you enjoyed it! I do love to write in rhyme...but it is so darn hard to get it right.

Reply
Jean Reidy link
2/4/2019 11:09:10 am

Great post, Vivian. And perfect list. May I use it in a talk I'm giving? I'll give you full attribution.

Reply
Vivian Kirkfield link
2/4/2019 07:01:23 pm

Of course, Jean...what a compliment to me! I've got a couple of presentations I need to cobble together also. :)

Reply
Mary Ann Cortez
2/4/2019 11:16:00 am

Such a great and much needed post.

Reply
Vivian Kirkfield link
2/4/2019 07:02:34 pm

So glad it will be helpful to you, Mary Ann.

Reply
Sarah Hetu-Radny link
2/4/2019 01:16:20 pm

Thanks for sharing the information on writing in rhyme, Vivian. I find keeping the rhythm correct to be hardest for me, when writing in rhyme. Actually, I try to avoid writing in rhyme...but I have this one manuscript that keeps yelling at me (from the pile of WIPs) to be worked on...darn, I can't avoid it forever!

Reply
Vivian Kirkfield link
2/4/2019 07:04:15 pm

I know exactly what you mean, Sarah...some stories just beg to be told in rhyme. Do you read it aloud? Or record yourself reading it and then listen back? That might help. ;)

Reply
Carol Gordon Ekster link
2/4/2019 04:06:19 pm

I don't write in rhyme because I'm terrible at it! This is a helpful post for those who want to try telling their story in rhyme. Great job, Vivian.

Reply
Vivian Kirkfield link
2/4/2019 08:34:26 pm

Hi Carol...thanks for stopping by and reading, even though you don't write in rhyme...but honestly, the rhythm of a prose picture book has to be there also, right. And I know you do that beautifully!

Reply
Renee LaTulippe link
2/4/2019 11:41:17 pm

A comprehensive list, to be sure, Vivian! And thanks for the shout-out! <3

Reply
Vivian Kirkfield link
2/16/2019 04:11:00 pm

Renee...thank you so much...and of course I have to give a shout out to you...you are such an amazing mentor and LLL was a great help to me! And I can hardly wait till April and getting to hug you in person in Florence...although I definitely don't want to wish away the next month and a half.

Reply
Diane Tulloch link
2/5/2019 12:06:18 pm

Very informative post, Vivian. By using this list I might try it one day. Thank you.

Reply
Vivian Kirkfield link
2/16/2019 04:12:20 pm

You could totally write in rhyme, Diane...some of your stories are already very poetic. :)

Reply
janet smart link
2/7/2019 01:02:07 pm

Your advice is spot on, Vivian. I love writing in rhyme, and quite a few of my manuscripts are written that way. Thanks for #8. It is a very good rule that I had never really thought of that much.

Reply
Vivian Kirkfield link
2/16/2019 04:14:40 pm

#8 is what tripped me up so many times, Janet. I didn't realize that we weren't supposed to 'make' it rhyme by changing up the rhythm or putting the emphasis on the wrong syllable. Maybe you'll do #50PreciousWords this year with a rhyming story. ;)

Reply
Roxanne N/A Harrington
2/22/2019 07:58:18 am

Thank you! Much to consider...

It certainly makes me quiver and quake --
I oft' rhyme just for rhyming's sake...

selah :-)

Reply
Stuart Blitz
9/3/2020 10:45:25 am

Hi Vivian,

My name is Stuart, I came across your article "Nine rhyme crimes to avoid when writing a rhyming picture book", it was very helpful.

My wife Meredith and my daughter (step, I hate using that term), are involved in a lawsuit against Court Appointed Psychologists for Malpractive (long story, her biological father started it)....no more about that.

I will be blunt, we are running out of money to pay for legal fees...

My wife is a 7th grade language arts teacher, she and I put together some children's books over the years.

I'm pleading with you, would you help by 1. critique them and 2. forward them on to your "critique buddies".

Best Regards
Stuart Blitz

Reply
takipçi satın al link
8/1/2022 04:00:20 am

Really informative article, I had the opportunity to learn a lot, thank you. https://takipcisatinalz.com/takipci-2/

Reply
define dedektor link
8/2/2022 12:13:25 am

Really informative article, I had the opportunity to learn a lot, thank you. https://www.ugurelektronik.com/

Reply
takipçi satın al link
8/3/2022 12:04:27 am

Really informative article, I had the opportunity to learn a lot, thank you. https://www.takipcikenti.com/instagram/turk-takipci/

Reply
okex kayıt olma link
8/9/2022 02:35:27 am

Really informative article, I had the opportunity to learn a lot, thank you. https://www.smsbankasi.net/2022/01/okex-nedir-nasl-kayt-olunur-nasl.html

Reply
walmart yurtdışı kargo link
8/9/2022 06:39:03 am

Really informative article, I had the opportunity to learn a lot, thank you. https://www.smsbankasi.net/2022/08/amazon-shopify-aliexpress-walmart-ebay.html

Reply
instagram takipçi satın al link
8/11/2022 02:44:49 pm

Really informative article, I had the opportunity to learn a lot, thank you. https://bit.ly/instagram-takipci-satin-al-takipci

Reply
weptekno link
9/10/2022 06:06:10 pm

En güncel haberleri weptekno.com sizin için hazırladı.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Authors

    We are a group of picture book authors and illustrators whose first picture books will be released in 2019. Read about our roads to publication here.

    Archives

    May 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018

    Categories

    All
    Author Interviews
    Illustrator Interviews
    Reviews
    Writing

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • About
  • Books
  • Book Trailers
  • Blog